Feedback for Code Reviews
Feedback in code review is how comments are written and received. Good feedback is specific, explains the reason, targets the code instead of the person, and separates required fixes from optional suggestions. Receiving feedback well means asking questions, avoiding defensiveness and treating comments as help.
Stage: Communication · Part of the Code Review roadmap · Last reviewed 19 November 2026
What to learn in Feedback
- Rewrite a blunt comment into a specific, respectful suggestion
- Label comments as blocking, suggestion or nitpick
- Ask a question instead of making an assumption about intent
- Respond to a disagreement with reasons and evidence
- Say thanks and follow up when a review comment is resolved
Feedback interview questions
How would you phrase a critical review comment kindly?
Describe the issue and the reason, then offer an option or a question, such as asking whether a null input could reach this line and suggesting a guard. Talk about the code, not the author, and acknowledge what is done well.
What should you do when you disagree with a reviewer's comment?
Ask for the reasoning, explain yours with evidence such as a benchmark or requirement, and look for a middle path. If you still disagree, involve a third person or follow the team's decision rule, and then move on.
Where Feedback fits in the Code Review roadmap
Feedback belongs to the Communication stage (intermediate level), which takes about 6 hours. Feedback that works.
Other units in this stage
Back to the full Code Review roadmap